Skip to content

Emily Tompkins

Emily Tompkins is a legal fellow at The Employment Law Group® law firm. Ms. Tompkins received her J.D. from The University of Missouri School of Law in May 2024. While in law school, she served as the associate editor-in-chief of the Journal of Dispute Resolution and was a student advocate in both the Entrepreneurship Legal Clinic and the Child and Family Justice Clinic.

Prior to law school, Ms. Tompkins graduated from the University of Rochester in May of 2021, where she earned a Bachelor of Arts in political science and philosophy.

Acadia Hospitals Reach $20 Million Settlement With Justice Dept.

Acadia Healthcare, one of the country’s largest for-profit chains of psychiatric hospitals, has agreed to pay nearly $20 million to settle a federal investigation accusing the company of defrauding taxpayer-funded health insurance programs like Medicare and Medicaid, the Justice Department said on Thursday.

Prosecutors said that Acadia had held patients for longer than necessary and admitted people who didn’t need to be there. Once patients entered its facilities, the government said, Acadia failed to provide therapy and kept staffing dangerously low, leading to assaults and suicides.

[…]

Another whistle-blower, Brian Snyder, who was an executive at Park Royal, said in an interview that the hospital systematically worked to hold patients with insurance as long as possible.

Mr. Snyder said the problems were widespread at Acadia. “It’s not by accident or a few bad apples,” he said, “it’s by design.”

>> View full story on The New York Times

 

[OFFICIAL ANNOUNCEMENT]

Acadia Healthcare Company Inc. to Pay $19.85M to Settle Allegations Relating to Medically Unnecessary Inpatient Behavioral Health Services

From the U.S. Department of Justice (September 26, 2024)

Acadia Healthcare Company Inc., a Delaware corporation with its principal place of business in Franklin, Tennessee, has agreed to resolve allegations that it violated the False Claims Act and related state statutes by knowingly billing for medically unnecessary inpatient behavioral health services or for services that did not meet federal and state regulations. Acadia Healthcare Company owns and operates inpatient behavioral health facilities throughout the United States, including The Pavilion at HealthPark LLC, doing business as Park Royal Hospital in Ft. Myers, Florida; Riverwoods Behavioral Health LLC, doing business as Lakeview Behavioral Health in Norcross, Georgia, and as Riverwoods Behavioral Health System in Riverdale, Georgia; Ten Broeck Tampa LLC, doing business as North Tampa Behavioral Health in Wesley Chapel, Florida; PHC of Michigan LLC, doing business as Harbor Oaks Hospital in New Baltimore, Michigan; and Seven Hills Hospital LLC, doing business as Seven Hills Hospital in Henderson, Nevada (collectively, Acadia).

» View press release on Justice.gov

 

[ADDITIONAL COVERAGE]

Acadia Healthcare Company pays settlement after whistleblower investigation

From KTNV Las Vegas (October 9, 2024)

HENDERSON (KTNV) — Acadia Healthcare Company Inc., which owns and operates Seven Hills Hospital in Henderson, has agreed to pay a settlement.

[…]

“My only hope is that this investigation and settlement will stop any future harms,” said Janel Quinn, a principal of The Employment Law Group, who represents two of the whistleblowers. “Psychiatric patients arrive in a fragile and deeply vulnerable state, and they deserve compassionate care — not to be detained for maximum dollars.”

Under the settlement agreement, Acadia will pay $16,663,918 to the U.S. to resolve its liability under the False Claims Act for false billings.

The company will also pay an additional $3,186,082 to Florida, Georgia, Michigan, and Nevada to resolve their state law claims against Acadia.

» View full story on KTNV

 

Acadia shares plummet on news of DOJ fine

From Nashville Post (September 27, 2024)

Acadia Healthcare has agreed to pay approximately $19.85 million to settle allegations that it violated the federal False Claims Act and related state statutes — with the stock of the Franklin-based company losing roughly 27 percent of value on the heels of the news.

In early morning trading, Acadia shares (ticker: ACHC) were priced at $55.66, down $20 per share.

According to a release from the U.S. Department of Justice, Acadia — which provides mental health treatment services — was charged with knowingly having billed either for medically unnecessary inpatient behavioral health services or for services that did not meet federal and state regulations.

» View full story on Nashville Post

 

Pasco, Lee hospitals named in $20M federal settlement

From the Business Observer (September 26, 2024)

Acadia Healthcare, a Tennessee medical group with behavioral hospitals in Fort Myers and Wesley Chapel, has agreed to pay $19.85 million to settle allegations that it “knowingly” billed for unnecessary medical services and services not meeting federal and state regulations at hospitals nationwide.

The settlement with the medical organization was announced Thursday by the United States Department of Justice. DOJ says Acadia will pay $16.6 million of the fine to the federal government and $3.18 million to Florida, Georgia, Michigan and Nevada to resolve state claims.

Among the allegations are that Acadia admitted people not eligible for inpatient treatment, failed to release people no longer in need of care and did not provide adequate supervision leading to violence and suicide.

» View full story on the Business Observer

 

Acadia Healthcare $19.85M Unnecessary Inpatient Settlement

From Lawyer Monthly (September 27, 2024)

Acadia Healthcare Company Inc., a corporation established in Delaware and headquartered in Franklin, Tennessee, has consented to settle claims asserting that it breached the False Claims Act and associated state laws by willfully submitting bills for inpatient behavioral health services that were not medically necessary or for services that failed to comply with federal and state regulations.

The United States asserted that from 2014 to 2017, Acadia intentionally submitted fraudulent claims for reimbursement to Medicare, Medicaid, and TRICARE for inpatient behavioral health services that were neither reasonable nor medically necessary.

» View full story on Lawyer Monthly

 

Former Acadia Employees Received Reward for Blowing the Whistle on Healthcare Fraud

From The National Law Review (September 26, 2024)

The United States Department of Justice settled a False Claims Act qui tam whistleblower lawsuit against inpatient behavioral health facilities operator Acadia Healthcare Company, Inc. Under the terms of the settlement, the operator paid almost $20 million to the United States and the States of Florida, Georgia, Michigan, and Nevada. The relators, or whistleblowers, who filed suit in 2017, received a reward of 19% of the government’s recovery of misspent Medicare, TRICARE, and Medicaid funds.

» View full story on The National Law Review

Chain of Psychiatric Hospitals Will Pay $19.9 Million to Settle Claims of Medicare Fraud Resulting from Patient Mistreatment

Former Executives Will Share in a $3.2 Million Award for Triggering Probe into Disturbing Practices at Acadia Healthcare Facilities

Complaint Alleges Involuntary Detention and Electroshock Therapy

———-

WASHINGTON, D.C. (September 26, 2024) — A national network of for-profit psychiatric hospitals agreed to pay nearly $20 million to resolve claims that it defrauded government insurance programs by mistreating patients and operating “like a prison,” in the words of two former executives who blew the whistle on its practices.

The U.S. Department of Justice today announced the settlement with Tennessee-based Acadia Healthcare, saying that Acadia was responsible for assaults and suicides at facilities where it failed to provide adequate staff, training, and supervision, among many violations of Medicare and other insurance programs.

The publicly traded company, which didn’t admit liability, also agreed to pay seven figures to settle additional retaliation claims and to cover whistleblower attorneys’ fees, costs, and expenses.

The federal government’s investigation was sparked by Franka Tirado and Brian Snyder, former Acadia executives who are represented by The Employment Law Group® law firm. Ms. Tirado resigned in 2016 because of Acadia’s practices; Mr. Snyder was fired in 2017 after repeatedly objecting to its actions as illegal.

Ms. Tirado and Mr. Snyder filed a lawsuit in 2017 against Acadia under the federal False Claims Act (FCA) and other laws, focusing on Acadia’s activities in Florida. The case remained secret while it was under investigation; it was unsealed earlier this week. A nursing director in Georgia filed related FCA claims against Acadia shortly afterward, bolstering the probe. The Employment Law Group does not represent the Georgia nursing director.

The $19.9 million settlement resolves both cases and covers Acadia’s conduct across four states: Florida, Georgia, Michigan, and Nevada.

The FCA, signed into law by President Abraham Lincoln in 1863, makes it illegal to claim payment from the federal government via deception. The law includes a “qui tam” provision that allows whistleblowers to file a complaint on behalf of the U.S. and — if they prevail — to receive a portion of any resulting settlement or judgment.

For disclosing Acadia’s actions, Ms. Tirado, Mr. Snyder, and the Georgia nursing director will share in a whistleblower award of more than $3 million. Mr. Snyder also will receive a separate payout from Acadia to settle his retaliation claim, as will the Georgia nursing director.

In addition to being probed by the federal government and multiple states, Acadia’s methods have drawn attention from The New York Times, which earlier this month published a scathing report about how Acadia “traps” and mistreats its psychiatric patients.

In their 2017 complaint, Ms. Tirado and Mr. Snyder outlined many examples of such disturbing practices at Acadia, including inappropriate admissions and involuntary detention of patients who should have been discharged. The whistleblower lawsuit also raised red flags about illegal kickbacks and Acadia’s use of electroconvulsive treatment without patient consent.

“Franka and Brian laid bare all of these troubling practices, and my only hope is that this investigation and settlement will stop any future harms,” said Janel Quinn, a principal of The Employment Law Group. “Psychiatric patients arrive in a fragile and deeply vulnerable state, and they deserve compassionate care — not to be detained for maximum dollars.”

Ms. Quinn represents Ms. Tirado and Mr. Snyder along with TELG principals R. Scott Oswald and Nicholas Woodfield. They worked in close cooperation with Sarah Arni, a senior trial counsel at the Justice Department; with former Assistant U.S. Attorney Lindsay Saxe Griffin at the U.S. Attorney’s Office for the Middle District of Florida; with Sara Vann at the National Association of Medicaid Fraud Control Units; and with Renée Brooker, Eva Gunasekera, and Jaclyn Tayabji of Tycko & Zavareei LLP, which represents the other whistleblower in the settlement.

———-

Case Information

United States ex rel. Tirado v. Park Royal Hospital
No. 2:17-cv-201
U.S. District Court for the Middle District of Florida
Complaint filed on April 13, 2017 (available here)

United States ex rel. Thompson v. Acadia Healthcare Company, Inc.
No. 2:18-cv-543
U.S. District Court for the Middle District of Florida
Complaint originally filed on April 17, 2017 as Case No. 1:17-cv-99 in the Eastern District of Tennessee (available here)

Note: The Employment Law Group is not involved in the Thompson case.

———-

About The Employment Law Group

The Employment Law Group® law firm represents whistleblowers and employees who stand up to wrongdoing in the workplace. Based in Washington, D.C., the firm takes cases nationwide.

How Long is Too Long for Delay on Reasonable Accommodations?

They say patience is a virtue. Does that mean the interactive process on an employee’s reasonable accommodation can go at a snail’s pace?

Not according to the court in Pelton v. DeJoy, No. 19-1766 (D.D.C. May 3, 2024), which indicated a four-year timeline between request and accommodation would be a delay too long to withstand a failure-to-accommodate challenge under the Rehabilitation Act.

The case involved an attorney hired by the U.S. Postal Service in 2013. Her disabilities included a spinal cord injury, cervical fusions, bilateral thoracic outlet syndrome, nerve damage, depression, and a genetic clotting disorder. During her time with the USPS, the attorney was diagnosed with or treated for peripheral nerve entrapment, carpal tunnel syndrome, tendon and ligament tears, tremors, anxiety, depression, chronic insomnia, and weight gain.

The attorney said she requested an ergonomic chair, desk, keyboard, and mouse during her first week on the job. She presented these requests to the employee who conducted her orientation, however, was told that there was no room in the budget. Instead, she was shown “a room full of broken office equipment” from which she was expected to select something that would work for her.

Mario Rizk

Mario Rizk is a part-time law student at Stetson University College of Law, where he is pursuing his Juris Doctor and expects to graduate in May 2027. He is also an alumnus of the University of Central Florida, where he earned a Bachelor of Arts in political science with a minor in philosophy.

Before joining The Employment Law Group® law firm as a law clerk, Mr. Rizk gained extensive experience as a litigation paralegal where he contributed to numerous multi-million-dollar settlements and verdicts by conducting comprehensive legal research, drafting legal documents, and developing litigation strategies.

Outside of his professional pursuits, Mr. Rizk enjoys participating in competitive chess tournaments and is actively engaged in exploring emerging technologies.

Deepika Sathe

Deepika Sathe is an evening student at Stetson University College of Law, where she expects to graduate in May 2026 with a concentration in social justice advocacy. At Stetson Law, Ms. Sathe serves on the executive board of the Immigration Law Student Association. She is also a member of Stetson Law’s Dispute Resolution Advocacy Board. Ms. Sathe earned a Master of Arts in Social Psychology from the University of Mumbai.

Ms. Sathe has extensive work experience in leadership skills development in India. Prior to joining The Employment Law Group® law firm, her US-based work experience was primarily with intellectual property law firms.

In her spare time, Ms. Sathe enjoys volunteering with animal welfare organizations and rescue groups, particularly Husky Haven of Florida.

Nelisa Inyang

Nelisa Inyang is a legal fellow at The Employment Law Group® law firm. Before joining The Employment Law Group, Ms. Inyang gained extensive experience at Buchanan Ingersoll & Rooney PC as a regulatory associate, advising on contracts and ensuring compliance with federal regulations. Additionally, Ms. Inyang clerked at the Prince George’s County Circuit Court and worked as a law clerk at Pitre & Associates, LLC.

Ms. Inyang received her J.D. from Howard University School of Law and a double degree in criminology and criminal justice and family science from the University of Maryland, College Park.
Ms. Inyang is admitted to practice law in Maryland and Washington, D.C.

AIA leadership addresses misconduct claims with independent investigation

In response to concerns raised by 22 former AIA presidents in a letter dated April 4, and another letter sent by this year’s FAIA selection committee dated April 2, AIA has engaged Miller & Chevalier, a Washington, D.C.–based law firm, for an independent investigation into the claims.

[…]

Former AIA general counsel Terrence Ona was terminated on April 24 after he was put on administrative leave for allegedly engaging in “potential misconduct” against Woods. (Ona was the person who reported [AIA CEO Lakisha Wood]’s financial activity to the AIA’s treasurer Heather Philip-O’Neal.) AIA’s head of human resources, Kiersten Thornton, told Ona he was being investigated for discrimination, and that he “targeted African-American/[B]lack women in his review.”

In turn, Ona filed a lawsuit against AIA in the Superior Court of the District of Columbia on June 6. Ona alleges that he’s been unlawfully discriminated against, unlawfully retaliated against, wrongfully terminated, and defamed by his former employer. He is suing for $2 million.

According to the lawsuit, Ona had been with the AIA since 2007 and possessed “a record of excellent performance and exceeded or met expectations at all relevant times prior to [AIA’s] discrimination.” The lawsuit claims that Ona was fired because of an inquiry he made into the actions of Woods and CSO Vicky Schneider.

Ona is bringing six charges against AIA. Court materials claim that AIA’s “illegal actions against Ona have damaged Ona’s reputation and have caused him to sustain economic damages and mental anguish.”

>> View full story on The Architect’s Newspaper

 

[ADDITIONAL COVERAGE]

 

American Institute of Architects CEO Accused of Misconduct

From Bloomberg (June 7, 2024)

Twenty-two past presidents of the American Institute of Architects signed a letter raising claims of misconduct against the organization’s current leadership, including concerns about misspending, nepotism and retaliation in the workplace.

The letter is one of a series of communications from professional architect groups, including state and local AIA chapters, charging that the national organization’s executive vice president and chief executive officer, Lakisha Ann Woods, has used the office to reward herself and allies. The CEO said in an interview there was no misconduct.

The AIA is also facing a lawsuit from the former chief counsel for the AIA, Terrence “Terry” Ona, for discrimination, wrongful termination and defamation.

>> View full story on Bloomberg

 

AIA members decry nepotism and other misconduct claims

From Archinect News (June 10, 2024)

Allegations of executive misconduct on the part of American Institute of Architects (AIA) CEO Lakisha Ann Woods and senior staffers who allegedly engaged in nepotism and other forms of unethical behavior have surfaced amidst the annual AIA24 conference that was held last week in Washington, D.C.

The list of accusations stemming from an April 4th letter signed by more than twenty past AIA presidents calls into question the organization’s leadership at a critical time. In an article published by Bloomberg late Friday, Woods and others were maligned for a series of missteps that includes a $152,000 staff retreat to the Dominican Republic in early March, unlawful firings and other retaliation, changes to the College of Fellows nominations process, and an increasingly toxic work culture within the AIA National ranks.

Additionally, as Bloomberg reported, former Chief Council Terrance Ona has recently entered an employment discrimination suit against the AIA, claiming he was unlawfully terminated in response to his March 25th internal complaint detailing Woods’ personal misuse of office privileges.

>> View full story on Archinect News